No BrainerBuys.

Published

Is it a real Black Friday deal? Check the model number, the "was" price and the price history

Before you trust a Black Friday price, run five checks: the exact model number, the "was" price, the price history, the manufacturer's list price and the offer terms. The FTC's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing say a former price is a fair comparison when it was the actual, bona fide price at which the item was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time. Black Friday 2026 is Friday, November 27, the day after Thanksgiving Day on Thursday, November 26. [S1] [S2]

Our take: match the full model number first, because a "deal" on a look-alike model proves nothing. Then treat the "was" price as a claim to test, not a fact: look at a dated price history for that exact model and ask whether the old price was really in use recently and for more than a few days. Compare with the manufacturer's own list price, knowing the FTC guide warns that a list price may not be the price at which items really sell. If the saving is tiny, the terms are vague or the history does not back up the old price, wait. That's our suggestion based on the text of 16 CFR Part 233. The guide gives no number of days for "reasonably substantial," so no checker can give you a pass or fail. [S1] [S2]

The five deal checks at a glance

What to check on any store's Black Friday price, with the line of the FTC guide behind it
The checkWhat to doWhich part of the guide
Model numberMatch the full model number, not just the product name, before comparing any price233.2: same merchandise, or a clear comparison to other merchandise
"Was" priceAsk whether it was a regular price, offered openly for a reasonably substantial time, recently233.1: former price comparisons
Price historyLook for the old price in a dated chart for the exact model; a brief spike is a warning sign233.1(d): not maintained for a reasonable length of time
List priceTreat "percent off list" with care; a list price may not be what items sell for233.3: manufacturer's list prices
Offer termsFor "free," "buy one" or "limited" offers, find every condition and limit before you buy233.4 and 233.5

Match the model. Test the "was" price. Check the history. Compare list price. Read the terms.

Original chart based on the text of 16 CFR Part 233, Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, as shown on eCFR on November 8, 2026. It is a plain-English reading, not legal advice. [S1]

Match the exact model number first

  1. Compare the full model number, not the product name. The same brand and product name can cover several versions, and a sale on one version says nothing about another. Write the model number down and use it for every check below. That's our suggestion.
  2. Look-alike versions are common. Our Bosch ICON suffix decoder shows one example: letters at the end of a part number point to different fit details, and a matching length alone does not make two blades the same. The same habit applies to any product with a model suffix.
  3. The FTC guide cares about what is being compared. Comparing against prices charged by others should be for the same merchandise. A comparison with other merchandise of like grade and quality is fine only when it is made clear to the consumer that other merchandise is being compared. [S1]
  4. If you can't find the model number, you can't run the other checks. That alone is a reason to pause. That's our suggestion.

Read the "was" price as a claim

  1. A fair former price is a real one. Section 233.1 says a former price provides a legitimate basis for a price comparison if it was the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time. [S1]
  2. A fictitious one is an inflated price made up to allow a big "reduction." The guide says that when the former price is not bona fide, the "bargain" is a false one, and the "reduced" price is probably just the seller's regular price. [S1]
  3. The price should be recent and honest. The guide says the former price should be one at which the product was openly and actively offered for sale, for a reasonably substantial period of time, in the recent, regular course of business, honestly and in good faith. [S1]
  4. It lists patterns that count as fictitious. Examples include a price the item was never offered at, a price not used in the regular course of business, a price used only at some remote time in the past without saying so, and a price not maintained for a reasonable length of time but immediately reduced. [S1]
  5. The guide doesn't give a number of days. "Reasonably substantial" is not defined in days in the text, so be wary of any claim that a specific number of days makes a "was" price fair or unfair. [S1]

Check the price history for the exact model

  1. Look for a dated chart. Use a tool or page that shows prices over time for the exact model number from step one. We do not name or rank any price tracker, and we have not tested one for this guide. That's our suggestion.
  2. Look for the "was" price in the last few weeks. If the old price shows up for a long stretch recently, the claim looks more believable. If it appears for a few days and then drops, that matches the guide's description of a price not maintained for a reasonable length of time but immediately reduced. [S1]
  3. If the old price never appears, ask why. The guide's examples of fictitious comparisons include a price at which the item was never offered. A chart with no sign of the old price is a reason to slow down, not proof of anything. [S1]
  4. Treat gaps as unknown. A third-party chart can miss days, stores or versions. Use it as a clue next to the other checks. That's our suggestion.
  5. Don't paste prices from a chart into your decision without the date. A price is only useful with the day it was seen. This guide itself reports no store's prices. That's our suggestion.

Compare with the list price, carefully

  1. Many shoppers read "list price" as the usual price. The guide says many people believe a manufacturer's list or suggested retail price is the price at which an article is generally sold, so an advertised reduction from it can look like a genuine bargain. [S1]
  2. It can mislead if few sales happen at that price. The guide says that to the extent list prices do not correspond to prices at which a substantial number of sales are made, advertising a reduction may mislead the consumer. [S1]
  3. Not every list price is fictitious. A list price is not fictitious if it is the price at which substantial sales are made in the area, but if it is significantly above the highest price at which substantial sales are made, there is a clear and serious danger of misleading the consumer. [S1]
  4. Use the maker's own page for the exact model. Find the manufacturer's listed price on its own site, note the date, and compare it with the price history from the last section. That's our suggestion.
  5. Look at the size of the saving. When an ad only says "Sale" and gives no old price, the guide says the reduction should not be so insignificant as to be meaningless. Its example: "Reduced to" a price one cent below the former price misleads. [S1]

Read the offer terms

  1. "Free," "buy one get one" and percentage-off deals come with conditions. Section 233.4 covers offers such as "Free," "Buy One Get One Free," "2-for-1," "half price" and percentage-off deals. It says all the terms and conditions should be made clear at the outset. [S1]
  2. Look for a higher regular price on the item you must buy. The guide says a consumer may be deceived where the seller increases the regular price of the required article, decreases its quantity or quality, or attaches other strings. [S1]
  3. "Limited" should mean limited. Section 233.5 says a seller should not make a "limited" offer that, in fact, is not limited, and should not offer an advance sale without a good-faith expectation of raising the price later. [S1]
  4. Seconds and imperfect items need a label. The same section says sellers should not offer seconds or imperfect or irregular merchandise at a reduced price without saying that the higher comparison price is for the item if perfect. [S1]
  5. Check the date before you buy. Thanksgiving Day is Thursday, November 26, 2026, and Black Friday is the next day, so a "Black Friday price" ad that appears earlier is worth the same four checks. [S2]

Deal checker

Pick what the ad shows and what you want to do. The tool combines wording from the cited pages. It does not look up any price. [S1]

Choose what the ad shows to start.

Black Friday deal checklist

Before you buy

Quick answers

How long does a "was" price have to last to be real?

The guide doesn't say. It uses the phrases "reasonably substantial period of time" and "recent, regular course of business" and gives no number of days. Treat any specific number you read elsewhere as someone's opinion, not the text of the guide. [S1]

What if the price is "elsewhere" or "compare at" another store?

Section 233.2 says the higher price must be based on fact and should not appreciably exceed the price at which substantial sales of the article are being made in the area. A price from only a few unrepresentative outlets would not be a fair comparison. [S1]

Can a price tracker prove a "was" price is fake?

No. A dated chart is a clue. It can show whether the old price appeared recently and for how long, but it can miss days, stores and versions. We don't name or rank price trackers, and none was tested for this guide.

Does the FTC guide say a deal is illegal?

This page only reads the guide's text. It does not say whether any store broke any rule, and it isn't legal advice. The guides describe what price comparisons should look like. [S1]

When is Black Friday 2026?

Friday, November 27, 2026. Thanksgiving Day is Thursday, November 26, 2026, on the federal holiday schedule, and Black Friday is the day after. [S2]

Does No Brainer Buys report any store's prices?

No. This guide has no prices and no deal listings. It explains how to test a price you find yourself.

Are products ranked here?

No. This guide explains the FTC's published pricing guide. It doesn't rank or endorse any product, store or price tool, and no products were tested for it.

Sources

Official pages checked November 8, 2026. Recommendations here are our editorial reading of those pages; no hands-on results are claimed. eCFR is a continuously updated online version of the CFR and is not an official legal edition.

  1. S1 · eCFR: 16 CFR Part 233, Guides Against Deceptive Pricing (sections 233.1 to 233.5; title 16 current through November 5, 2026)
  2. S2 · OPM: Federal Holidays (2026 schedule, Thanksgiving Day Thursday, November 26)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.